Colonial Penn life insurance review

(844) 717-5170(844) 760-0427
Colonial Penn life insurance review

Colonial Penn life insurance review

Our free guide allows you to create a custom end-of-life plan on your own terms.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Colonial Penn life insurance review
Colonial Penn life insurance review

It pays to plan ahead
Preplan your own funeral arrangement online in minutes
See Pricing
Arrange Immediate
Cremation Services
Speak to our dedicated care specialists now
We're here to help 24/7
Call Us

Written by the After editorial team · Rates checked November 12, 2026 · Last updated November 12, 2026

After isn't affiliated with Colonial Penn and doesn't sell Colonial Penn policies. Colonial Penn is named for identification only.

Quick verdict: Colonial Penn's main policy is Guaranteed Acceptance Whole Life for people 50 to 85 in most states. It asks no health questions and is sold in units that cost $9.95 a month each. What one unit pays depends on your age, sex and state when you buy, and the policy has a 2-year limited benefit period.

Most people meet Colonial Penn through a television ad that promises coverage for $9.95 a month, and then spend an evening trying to work out what that $9.95 actually buys. This review answers that question with the company's own published terms, a dated look at what a unit is worth at different ages, the ratings and complaint records as they stood on November 12, 2026, and an even number of recent customer reviews from each side. If what you really want is to have the cremation itself arranged and paid for, rather than a check your family has to turn into arrangements, you can also look at After's prepaid cremation plans.

Who is Colonial Penn, and who issues the policies?

Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company is a Philadelphia-based insurer that issues its own policies and has sold life insurance by mail, phone and television since 1957. It is part of CNO Financial Group (NYSE: CNO), the same parent that owns Bankers Life and Washington National, and it reports more than 820,000 policies in force.

The company was founded by Leonard Davis, a philanthropist who also co-founded AARP, and in 1968 it became one of the first insurers to offer a guaranteed acceptance policy made only for people 50 and older, according to Colonial Penn's company page. That history matters for a practical reason, which is that when you buy from Colonial Penn you are buying directly from the insurer that will pay the claim, with no agency or marketing company standing in between.

What does Colonial Penn sell to people over 50?

Colonial Penn sells one core product to people over 50, which is Guaranteed Acceptance Whole Life, and it markets that same policy under several names, including senior life insurance, final expense insurance and burial insurance. If you would like the wider picture first, our guides to burial insurance explained and burial insurance vs life insurance cover how these policies differ from one another.

Here is what the company's own pages said on November 12, 2026:

  • Guaranteed Acceptance Whole Life (the "$9.95 plan"). Issue ages are 50 to 85 in most states, with narrower ranges in a few places, such as 50 to 75 in New York, Minnesota and Missouri and 56 to 85 in Pennsylvania. There are no health questions and no medical exam, so you can't be turned down for health reasons. Source: Colonial Penn's Guaranteed Acceptance page.
  • How the units work. Each unit costs $9.95 a month, and you can buy up to 25 units. The benefit attached to each unit is set by your age, your sex (age only in Montana) and your state on the day the coverage starts, which means two people paying the same $9.95 can own very different amounts of coverage. Source: Colonial Penn's $9.95 FAQ.
  • What stays fixed. Once the policy is issued, the premium is guaranteed never to rise and the benefit doesn't shrink as you age. Coverage stays in force for as long as the premiums are paid.
  • Cash value. The policy starts building cash value after the first year, and you can borrow against it at 8% interest compounded annually. Any unpaid loan and interest are taken out of the death benefit.
  • Easy-issue whole life. Colonial Penn's company page also mentions a whole life policy with health questions, but the public product pages don't list its ages or coverage amounts, so you would need to ask for those on a call.
  • Term life. We found no term life product on colonialpenn.com.

Colonial Penn's own comparison chart describes typical coverage on the guaranteed acceptance policy as $2,000 to $25,000, which puts it squarely in the range people buy to cover a funeral or cremation and a few final bills.

How much does Colonial Penn cost by age?

Colonial Penn costs $9.95 a month per unit at every age, and what changes with age is how much coverage each unit buys. The company doesn't publish a national chart of benefit per unit, so the dollar figures below come from third-party sources and are shown only as dated examples, not as Colonial Penn's current rates.

The clearest way to think about this policy is to turn the usual question around. With most insurers you choose a coverage amount and the price moves with your age. With Colonial Penn the price per unit is fixed and the coverage moves, so the older you are when you buy, the less each $9.95 is worth.

Illustrative coverage per $9.95 unit, as reported by Asurgo (which credits colonialpenn.com quotes from March 2026 and notes that values vary by state) and matched by the chart in NerdWallet's review:

  • Age 50: about $1,669 for a man and $2,000 for a woman
  • Age 55: about $1,420 for a man and $1,761 for a woman
  • Age 60: about $1,167 for a man and $1,515 for a woman
  • Age 65: about $896 for a man and $1,258 for a woman
  • Age 70: about $689 for a man and $1,000 for a woman
  • Age 75: about $549 for a man and $762 for a woman
  • Age 80: about $426 for a man and $608 for a woman

Rates checked November 12, 2026. Your own quote will depend on your state, so treat these as a pattern and ask Colonial Penn for the exact benefit per unit before you buy.

To see what that means in monthly dollars, take a 65-year-old man who wants roughly $10,000 of coverage. At about $896 per unit he would need 12 units, which comes to $119.40 a month for about $10,750 of coverage, a figure that lines up with the example Choice Mutual publishes. Choice Mutual is an agency that earns commissions from other carriers, so its comparisons deserve the same careful reading as anyone else's. For a broader sense of the market, see what burial insurance costs.

Does Colonial Penn have a waiting period, and who qualifies?

Yes. Colonial Penn's Guaranteed Acceptance Whole Life has a 2-year limited benefit period. Colonial Penn's own FAQ says that if you die before the 2 years end, the policy will not pay the full death benefit, and that full benefits become payable once that period has passed.

The company's product page describes the policy as "a graded death benefit contract with a limited death benefit payment in the first 2 years," and its limited benefit FAQ confirms the 2-year window. The public pages we read don't spell out the exact amount paid during those 2 years. Third-party reviewers describe it as a return of the premiums paid plus interest for a death from natural causes, with accidental death generally paid in full, and you should ask Colonial Penn to show you that language in the policy itself before you rely on it.

A waiting period like this is the trade that comes with any guaranteed acceptance policy, and it helps to know the three ways life insurance is usually approved:

  • Guaranteed issue asks no health questions and accepts everyone in the age range, and in exchange it limits the benefit for the first 2 years.
  • Simplified issue asks a short list of health questions with no exam, and people who qualify usually get full coverage from the first day.
  • Fully underwritten coverage involves detailed questions and often an exam, and it rewards good health with the most coverage for each dollar.

Anyone within the issue ages for their state qualifies for Colonial Penn's guaranteed acceptance policy, and there is no membership requirement. West Virginia residents can't buy benefits of less than $1,000.

What are the pros and cons of Colonial Penn?

Colonial Penn's strengths are certainty of acceptance and a premium that never changes. Its trade-offs are a 2-year limited benefit period and a unit system in which the same $9.95 buys less coverage the older you are when you start. Each point below ties back to a fact in the sections above.

Pros

  • Acceptance is guaranteed. With no health questions and no exam, people 50 to 85 in most states can't be declined because of their health.
  • The price and the benefit are locked. Once the policy is issued, the premium can never rise and the benefit doesn't decrease with age.
  • You buy from the insurer. Colonial Penn issues its own policies and holds an A (Excellent) financial strength rating from AM Best.
  • There is a 30-day window to change your mind. Colonial Penn calls it a "Try-It-On Period," and you can cancel within it for a full refund.

Cons

  • The full benefit isn't available for 2 years. A death from natural causes in that window pays a limited benefit, not the face amount.
  • Coverage per dollar falls with age. In the third-party examples above, a unit that buys about $1,669 for a 50-year-old man buys about $426 for an 80-year-old man.
  • Total coverage is modest. With a 25-unit cap, Colonial Penn's own chart describes typical coverage as $2,000 to $25,000.
  • Exact benefits aren't published. You need a quote to learn what a unit pays in your state, which makes side-by-side comparison slower than it should be.

Is Colonial Penn legit? Ratings, reviews and complaints

Yes, Colonial Penn is a legitimate, state-regulated insurer. It has operated since 1957, it is owned by publicly traded CNO Financial Group, and it holds an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best. Its customer review scores are low on independent sites, and complaint data reported by third parties runs above the industry average.

Here is how the numbers stood when we checked them on November 12, 2026:

  • AM Best financial strength: A (Excellent) with a stable outlook, per CNO Financial Group's ratings page. This rating speaks to the company's ability to pay claims, not to customer service.
  • Better Business Bureau: A+ rating and accredited since March 18, 2020. Customer reviews on the same profile average 1.06 out of 5 across roughly 160 reviews, with 179 complaints filed in the last 3 years and 49 in the last 12 months. Source: BBB profile. The BBB letter grade reflects how a business responds to complaints, which is why it can sit beside a low customer score.
  • Trustpilot: TrustScore of 1.3 out of 5 from 105 reviews, of which 95% are 1-star. Trustpilot notes that Colonial Penn hasn't replied to negative reviews there. Source: Trustpilot.
  • Google: 3.1 out of 5 across 608 reviews, as compiled by Choice Mutual on June 17, 2026.
  • NAIC complaints: NerdWallet reports that Colonial Penn drew far more complaints than expected for its size over 3 years, based on National Association of Insurance Commissioners data. You can look up the current complaint index yourself on the NAIC consumer site, where 1.00 is the national median.
  • Regulatory actions: We found no state insurance department action or lawsuit from 2023 to 2026 in the sources we reviewed.

What recent customers say

We looked for the most recent positive and negative reviews we could link to directly, and we show the same number of each. Positive reviews are scarce on the independent platforms, where only 1 of the 100 most recent Trustpilot reviews carries 4 or 5 stars, so we are showing 1 of each instead of padding either side.

  • Positive, May 1, 2024 (Trustpilot, 5 stars). Bonnie H. wrote to retract an earlier negative review, saying the company reached out to her afterward and that she now considers it "very trustworthy." Read the review.
  • Negative, November 12, 2026 (Trustpilot, 1 star). Kandi E. wrote that she was charged for a policy she says she never approved, and that canceling had to be done by mail and took about 3 to 4 weeks. Read the review.

Across the BBB and Trustpilot pages, the complaint themes that come up most often are charges that customers say began sooner than they expected after a quote, cancellations that had to be requested in writing, and surprise at the limited benefit period. These are customers' own accounts, and they are a good reason to read the policy terms slowly and to ask for the benefit per unit in writing.

Who is Colonial Penn a good fit for, and who should look elsewhere?

Colonial Penn fits people 50 to 85 who can't qualify for coverage that asks health questions and who want a small policy with a guaranteed price. People in reasonably good health, and people who want a specific dollar amount or want the arrangements themselves handled, usually have better-suited options. Our life insurance company reviews groups 34 insurers by the kind of policy they mainly sell.

Colonial Penn may fit if:

  • You have a health condition that would get you declined for a policy with health questions, and you want certainty of acceptance. Gerber Life's Guaranteed Life Insurance is another no-health-questions policy worth comparing.
  • You value a monthly price that is fixed for life and you are comfortable with a modest benefit.

You may want to look elsewhere if:

  • You want a specific amount of coverage, such as $10,000 or $15,000, because the unit system makes that amount more expensive the later you start. Globe Life, by contrast, publishes rate tables for set coverage amounts.
  • You are in good enough health to answer a few questions, in which case a simplified issue policy, such as Mutual of Omaha's Living Promise, may give you full coverage from the first day.
  • What you want most is for the cremation itself to be arranged and its price locked, so your family isn't left to plan and pay in the same week they are grieving.

Colonial Penn vs a prepaid cremation plan: what's the difference?

Colonial Penn pays your beneficiary a cash benefit, and your family then plans and pays for everything themselves. A prepaid cremation plan from After pays for the cremation services named in the plan, which are arranged ahead of time. Life insurance pays money and a prepaid plan pays for the service, and some families choose to have both.

  • What it pays. Colonial Penn pays a fixed cash amount to your beneficiary, set on the day you buy. After's prepaid plan covers the cremation services in the plan, and an optional Memorial Fund can add a $1,000 to $2,500 cash benefit for a celebration of life (after.com/prearrange, checked November 12, 2026). For context on what a cremation runs today, see the average cremation cost.
  • Price lock. Colonial Penn's premium is level, but the benefit doesn't rise with funeral prices, so the same check may cover less in 15 years than it would today. After's Crest and Summit plans list a price lock guarantee against price increases, and the Base plan doesn't include one.
  • Medical questions. Colonial Penn's guaranteed acceptance policy asks none. For After's plans, ask a Care Specialist which questions apply to you when you get your quote.
  • Waiting period. Colonial Penn has a 2-year limited benefit period. After's explainer on whether a prepaid cremation plan is safe describes a standard 2-year contestable period on its plans and says that it isn't a waiting period.
  • What the family still has to do. With Colonial Penn, your family files a claim with a certified death certificate, waits for the payment, and then chooses a provider, makes every arrangement and pays for it, a process we walk through in paying for a funeral with life insurance. With After, your family makes one call, and the transportation, the cremation and the services in the plan are already arranged.
  • Where it's available. Colonial Penn sells in most states, with issue ages that vary by state. After provides cremation services only where it holds the required state licenses.

If you'd like to understand the mechanics before deciding anything, our guides to how prepaid cremation works, preneed funeral contracts and cremation insurance explain each option in plain terms.

Want the cremation itself arranged and paid for at today's price? See After's prepaid cremation plans or call 844-431-1320. Plans start as low as $25 a month, and there's no pressure to decide on the first call. We provide cremation services only where we hold the required state licenses (see our licenses).

Colonial Penn FAQ

Is Colonial Penn legit?

Yes. Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company is a licensed insurer that has operated since 1957 and is owned by CNO Financial Group. It holds an A (Excellent) financial strength rating from AM Best. Its customer review scores are low, with a 1.3 TrustScore on Trustpilot as of November 12, 2026, so read the policy terms carefully before you buy.

Does Colonial Penn have a waiting period?

Yes. Colonial Penn's Guaranteed Acceptance Whole Life has a 2-year limited benefit period. If you die from natural causes during those 2 years, the policy pays a limited benefit and not the full face amount. After 2 years, the full benefit is payable for any cause of death.

How much does Colonial Penn life insurance cost?

Colonial Penn charges $9.95 a month per unit, and you can buy up to 25 units. The coverage in each unit depends on your age, sex and state. Third-party charts dated 2026 show a unit worth about $896 for a 65-year-old man and about $1,258 for a 65-year-old woman, though your quote may differ.

Can I cancel a Colonial Penn policy?

Yes. Colonial Penn offers a 30-day "Try-It-On Period" during which you can cancel for a full refund. After that you can still cancel, but you won't get your premiums back beyond any cash value the policy has built. Colonial Penn's service line is 1-800-523-9100, and recent reviewers say the company asked them for a written request.

Does Colonial Penn life insurance pay for cremation?

Colonial Penn pays cash to your beneficiary, who can use it for a cremation or for anything else. The policy doesn't arrange a cremation, choose a provider or lock in a price. If you want those things handled ahead of time, a prepaid cremation plan is built for that job.

What is the downside to Colonial Penn life insurance?

The main trade-offs with Colonial Penn are the 2-year limited benefit period and the unit pricing, under which each $9.95 buys less coverage the older you are when you start. Coverage is also capped at 25 units, which Colonial Penn describes as typically $2,000 to $25,000.

How should seniors compare life insurance companies?

Compare the same 4 things at every company: the coverage amount in dollars for your exact age, the monthly premium and whether it can rise, any waiting or limited benefit period, and the insurer's financial strength rating. Then check complaint records with the NAIC and your state insurance department before you sign.

What does Colonial Penn give you for $9.95 a month?

For $9.95 a month, Colonial Penn gives you 1 unit of Guaranteed Acceptance Whole Life coverage. The dollar value of that unit depends on your age, sex and state on the day you buy. Third-party examples from 2026 range from about $2,000 for a 50-year-old woman to about $426 for an 80-year-old man.

Does Colonial Penn actually pay out?

Colonial Penn is a licensed insurer with an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best, which reflects its financial ability to pay claims. Claims in the first 2 years of a guaranteed acceptance policy are limited by the policy's terms, and that limit is a common source of the complaints posted online.

For more answers about planning ahead, see our pre-planning FAQs.

Ready to see what a plan costs? See After's prepaid cremation plans, compare prepaid cremation plan pricing, or call 844-431-1320 whenever you're ready. We provide cremation services only where we hold the required state licenses (see our licenses).

Sources

All sources accessed November 12, 2026.

  • Colonial Penn, Guaranteed Acceptance Life Insurance: https://colonialpenn.com/products/guaranteedacceptance
  • Colonial Penn, "How does Colonial Penn's $9.95 guaranteed acceptance whole life insurance work?": https://colonialpenn.com/service-support/faq/How-does-Colonial-Penns-$9.95-guaranteed-acceptance-whole-life-insurance-work
  • Colonial Penn, "What is a two-year limited benefit period?": https://colonialpenn.com/service-support/faq/What-is-a-two-year-limited-benefit-period
  • Colonial Penn, Our Company: https://colonialpenn.com/our-company
  • CNO Financial Group, Financial Ratings: https://ir.cnoinc.com/financial-information/financial-ratings
  • Better Business Bureau, Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company: https://www.bbb.org/us/pa/philadelphia/profile/insurance-companies/colonial-penn-life-insurance-company-0241-80001800
  • Trustpilot, Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company: https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.colonialpenn.com
  • NerdWallet, Colonial Penn Life Insurance Review (February 24, 2026): https://www.nerdwallet.com/insurance/life/colonial-penn-life-insurance-review
  • Asurgo, Colonial Penn Rate Chart by Age (last reviewed August 2026): https://asurgo.com/insurance-reviews/colonial-penn/rate-chart/
  • Choice Mutual, Colonial Penn review (modified June 8, 2026): https://choicemutual.com/life-insurance-reviews/colonial-penn/
  • NAIC Consumer Information Source: https://content.naic.org/cis_consumer_information.htm
  • After, Prepaid Cremation Plans: https://www.after.com/prearrange
We're here to help
Simple cremations. Upfront prices. Your way.

Save thousands compared to traditional funeral homes.

Arrange simple cremation services online in minutes

A dedicated care specialist to support you every step of the way.

We're here to help 24/7

Related posts

No items found.

Related posts

Call us