
It pays to plan ahead
Preplan your own funeral arrangement online in minutes
Arrange Immediate
Cremation Services
Cremation Services
Speak to our dedicated care specialists now
We're here to help 24/7
Call Us
Written by the After editorial team · Rates checked November 12, 2026 · Last updated November 12, 2026
After isn't affiliated with New York Life and doesn't sell New York Life policies. New York Life is named for identification only.
Quick verdict: New York Life is a mutual insurer, founded in 1845, that issues its own term, whole and universal life policies through agents and also underwrites the AARP Life Insurance Program. It suits people who want a top-rated company and an advisor, and the main catch is that agent-sold policies have no published rates.
People who search for New York Life reviews tend to find a confusing mix of pages, because the same name sits on agent-sold whole life, on AARP policies advertised by mail, and on workplace disability coverage. This review separates those pieces for readers over 50, using New York Life's own pages, the ratings and complaint records as of November 12, 2026, and an even number of recent customer reviews from each side. If what you really want is to have the cremation itself arranged and paid for, so your family isn't handed a check and a list of decisions, you can also look at After's prepaid cremation plans.
Who is New York Life, and who issues the policies?
New York Life Insurance Company is a mutual life insurer that was founded in 1845 and is headquartered in New York City. It issues its own policies, which means the company that sells you the coverage is the one that pays the claim, and it also underwrites the AARP Life Insurance Program for AARP members.
Being a mutual company means New York Life is owned by its participating policy owners and not by shareholders. In its January 5, 2026 announcement, New York Life called itself America's largest mutual life insurer and said it expected to pay about $2.78 billion in dividends to eligible policy owners in 2026, its 172nd consecutive annual payout. Dividends are never guaranteed, and New York Life's own whole life page says so in its footnotes.
What does New York Life sell to people over 50?
New York Life sells people over 50 two different sets of products: agent-sold term, whole and universal life policies that are individually underwritten, and the AARP Life Insurance Program, which offers smaller term, permanent and guaranteed acceptance coverage to AARP members ages 50 and up without a medical exam.
Our guides to burial insurance explained and burial insurance vs life insurance cover how these kinds of policies differ, and here is what New York Life's own pages said on November 12, 2026:
- New York Life whole life insurance (agent-sold). The whole life page lists Whole Life, Custom Whole Life (which lets you finish paying premiums in a shorter period, such as 10 or 20 years), Secure Wealth Plus and Custom Survivorship Whole Life, which covers 2 people. They build cash value and are eligible for dividends, and the page doesn't publish issue ages or coverage minimums.
- Term life (agent-sold). The term life page describes yearly renewable term, where premiums start low and rise each year, and level term for 10, 15 or 20 years. Some term policies can be converted to permanent coverage, generally within the first 10 years.
- Universal and variable universal life (agent-sold). New York Life also lists these 2 kinds of permanent coverage, which are quoted through an agent.
- AARP Level Benefit Term Life. For AARP members ages 50 to 74 and spouses or partners 45 to 74, with $10,000 to $150,000 of coverage that can last to age 80. Acceptance depends on health questions, and rates aren't guaranteed and rise in 5-year age bands. Source: nylaarp.com term page.
- AARP Permanent Life. Whole life coverage of up to $100,000 for members ages 50 to 80, with health questions, no medical exam and a rate that never increases. Source: nylaarp.com permanent page.
- AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life. Up to $30,000 for members ages 50 to 85 and spouses or partners 45 to 85, with no health questions. The cap is $25,000 and the top age is 80 in a few places, including Minnesota, Missouri, Montana and Oregon, and New York residents can apply from 50 to 75. Source: nylaarp.com guaranteed acceptance page.
New York Life doesn't sell a product named burial insurance or final expense insurance, so the closest match to New York Life burial insurance is the AARP guaranteed acceptance or permanent policy. AARP membership is required for all 3 AARP products, which we cover in our AARP life insurance review.
How much does New York Life cost by age?
New York Life doesn't publish rates for its agent-sold policies, so the only way to learn your price is to get a quote from a New York Life agent. The AARP program does publish starting prices, such as $13 a month for $5,000 of permanent coverage for a 50-year-old woman who doesn't smoke.
There is no rate chart on newyorklife.com, and we won't estimate agent-sold prices here. New York Life's guide to whole life cost says the price depends on your age, gender, health, lifestyle, occupation and death benefit.
The figures New York Life does publish are on the AARP program pages, rates checked November 12, 2026:
- AARP Permanent Life: $13 a month for $5,000 of coverage, for a woman age 50 who doesn't smoke.
- AARP Level Benefit Term Life: $11 a month for $10,000 of coverage, for a woman age 50 who doesn't smoke, with rates that aren't guaranteed and rise in 5-year age bands.
- AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life: no sample rate is published, and the page says your rate is set by your age when you apply and never increases.
Here are monthly premiums for $10,000 of coverage under the 2 AARP whole life policies, as published by Choice Mutual, an agency that earns commissions from other carriers and credits its own quote calculator as of March 9, 2026. These are a third party's dated examples, checked November 13, 2026, not New York Life's current rates.
- Age 50: Guaranteed Acceptance about $44 for a man and $33 for a woman, and Permanent Life about $33 and $24
- Age 60: Guaranteed Acceptance about $60 for a man and $44 for a woman, and Permanent Life about $50 and $36
- Age 70: Guaranteed Acceptance about $84 for a man and $64 for a woman, and Permanent Life about $81 and $62
- Age 80: Guaranteed Acceptance about $144 for a man and $112 for a woman, and Permanent Life about $122 and $92
Your own quote will depend on your state, tobacco use and health answers, so ask New York Life for the exact premium in writing. For a broader look, see what burial insurance costs.
Does New York Life have a waiting period, and who qualifies?
New York Life's pages describe no waiting period on its agent-sold policies, which are underwritten before they are issued. The one New York Life product with a stated waiting period is AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life, which pays a limited benefit of 110% of premiums paid if you die of natural causes in the first 2 years.
The program's guaranteed acceptance FAQ says that full benefits are paid for accidental death from the first day, and that a few states set their own minimums for those first 2 years.
It helps to know the 3 ways life insurance is usually approved, because New York Life uses all of them:
- Guaranteed issue asks no health questions and accepts everyone in the age range, and in exchange it limits the benefit for the first 2 years.
- Simplified issue asks health questions with no exam, and people who are accepted usually have full coverage from the first day, as with the AARP permanent and term policies.
- Fully underwritten coverage involves detailed questions and often medical and lab tests, as with most agent-sold New York Life policies.
Who qualifies depends on which route you take, because the AARP products require membership and are limited to the ages listed above, while agent-sold policies depend on your health and on what an agent can offer in your state.
What are the pros and cons of New York Life?
New York Life's strengths are its financial ratings, its long dividend record and a product range that runs from small AARP policies to large whole life. Its trade-offs are that agent-sold prices aren't published, most agent-sold policies require underwriting, and the guaranteed acceptance policy limits benefits for 2 years.
Pros
- The financial strength ratings are at the top of the scale. New York Life holds A++ from AM Best, AAA from Fitch, Aa1 from Moody's and AA+ from S&P, according to its January 5, 2026 announcement.
- Policy owners share in the results. As a mutual company, New York Life has paid dividends to eligible participating policy owners for 172 consecutive years, though dividends aren't guaranteed.
- There is a path for most health situations. The AARP program offers a no-exam permanent policy with health questions and a guaranteed acceptance policy with none, for members ages 50 to 85.
- Complaints run below what its size would predict. NerdWallet reports that New York Life drew fewer complaints to state regulators than expected over 3 years.
Cons
- Agent-sold rates aren't published. You need to speak with a New York Life agent to get a price, which makes it slower to compare against other insurers.
- Most agent-sold policies require underwriting. New York Life's whole life page says traditional underwriting may include medical and lab tests.
- The guaranteed acceptance policy has a 2-year limited benefit. A death from natural causes in that window pays 110% of the premiums paid, not the full amount.
- AARP term rates rise with age. Level Benefit Term rates aren't guaranteed, increase in 5-year age bands, and the coverage ends at age 80.
Is New York Life legit? Ratings, reviews and complaints
Yes, New York Life is a legitimate, state-regulated insurer that has operated since 1845 and holds an A++ rating from AM Best. Its regulatory complaint record is lighter than expected for its size, while its scores on customer review sites are low, and most of the recent reviews we read concern workplace disability claims.
Here is how the numbers stood when we checked them on November 12, 2026:
- AM Best financial strength: A++, the highest rating AM Best gives, as of August 1, 2025, per New York Life's ratings announcement. The same release lists AAA from Fitch, Aa1 from Moody's and AA+ from S&P.
- Better Business Bureau: A+ rating, not BBB accredited, with 284 complaints in the last 3 years and 52 in the last 12 months, alongside more than 240 customer reviews. Source: BBB profile.
- Trustpilot: TrustScore of 1.3 out of 5 from 71 reviews. The profile is unclaimed, and New York Life hasn't invited customers to review there. Source: Trustpilot.
- NAIC complaints: NerdWallet reports that New York Life drew fewer than the expected number of complaints to state regulators over 3 years, based on National Association of Insurance Commissioners data. You can look up the current index yourself on the NAIC consumer site, where 1.00 is the national median and New York Life's company code is 66915.
- J.D. Power: NerdWallet reports that New York Life ranked No. 8 of 22 companies for customer satisfaction in J.D. Power's 2025 U.S. Individual Life Insurance Study.
- Lawsuits and regulatory actions: In January 2024 the Washington insurance commissioner fined New York Life $46,328 because it hadn't verified that 22 producers completed required long-term care training before selling that product, according to the commissioner's announcement. In February 2024, New York Life agreed to pay $19 million to settle a class action by its own employees and agents over their 401(k) plan investments, as InvestmentNews reported. That case concerned workplace retirement plans and not life insurance policies or claims.
What recent customers say
We looked for the most recent positive and negative reviews we could link to directly, and we show the same number of each. We found only 3 reviews with 5 stars among the Trustpilot reviews posted since January 2024, and 1 of them reads as if it came from someone who works with the company, so we are showing 2 of each instead of padding either side.
- Positive, March 1, 2026 (Trustpilot, 5 stars). John T. left a short review saying that he considers New York Life a high-quality company that treats people fairly. Read the review.
- Negative, November 10, 2026 (Trustpilot, 1 star). Eliza H. wrote that a premium was deducted twice after her policy changed at age 80, and that she found the phone support hard to follow. Read the review.
- Positive, August 20, 2025 (Trustpilot, 5 stars). Carlos O. wrote that the service he received felt personal and that the recommendations were tailored to his situation. Read the review.
- Negative, November 4, 2026 (Trustpilot, 1 star). T. H., who described themselves as a clinician, wrote that the company was slow and unsupportive toward people on medical leave from work. Read the review.
Across the BBB and Trustpilot pages, the theme that comes up most often is slow or stalled short-term disability and leave claims handled by New York Life's group benefits division, which people reach through an employer. Among reviews about life insurance, customers describe long hold times, repeated paperwork requests, and disappointment with an older policy's cash value or cost. These are customers' own accounts, and they are a good reason to ask an agent for every figure in writing.
Who is New York Life a good fit for, and who should look elsewhere?
New York Life fits people who want a mutual insurer with top financial ratings and are comfortable buying through an agent, as well as AARP members ages 50 to 85 who want a smaller policy without an exam. People who want to compare prices online, or want the arrangements themselves handled, usually have better-suited options. See every life insurance company we've reviewed to compare other companies.
New York Life may fit if:
- You want permanent coverage that builds cash value and may earn dividends, designed with an agent. Northwestern Mutual, another mutual insurer, sells similar coverage through its own advisors.
- You're an AARP member between 50 and 85 who wants a modest policy with no medical exam.
You may want to look elsewhere if:
- You want to compare prices online before you talk with anyone, because agent-sold rates aren't published. Globe Life, for example, publishes its rate tables.
- You're older than 85, which is past the top issue age for the AARP guaranteed acceptance policy.
- What you want most is for the cremation itself to be arranged and its price locked, so your family isn't left to plan and pay in the same week they are grieving.
New York Life vs a prepaid cremation plan: what's the difference?
New York Life pays your beneficiary a cash death benefit, and your family then plans and pays for everything themselves. A prepaid cremation plan from After pays for the cremation services named in the plan, which are arranged ahead of time. Life insurance pays money and a prepaid plan pays for the service, and some families choose to have both.
- What it pays. New York Life pays a fixed cash amount to your beneficiary, set when you buy. After's prepaid plan covers the cremation services in the plan, and an optional Memorial Fund can add a $1,000 to $2,500 cash benefit for a celebration of life (after.com/prearrange, checked November 12, 2026). For context on what a cremation runs today, see the average cremation cost.
- Price lock. New York Life's whole life premiums are level, but the benefit isn't tied to funeral prices, so the same check may cover less in 15 years than it would today. After's Crest and Summit plans list a price lock guarantee against price increases, and the Base plan doesn't include one.
- Medical questions. New York Life's agent-sold policies are underwritten, the AARP permanent and term policies ask health questions, and AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life asks none. For After's plans, ask a Care Specialist which questions apply to you when you get your quote.
- Waiting period. AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life has a 2-year limited benefit period, and New York Life's pages describe none on its other policies. After's explainer on whether a prepaid cremation plan is safe describes a standard 2-year contestable period on its plans and says that it isn't a waiting period.
- What the family still has to do. With New York Life, your family reports the death, files a claim and waits for the payment, and then chooses a provider, makes every arrangement and pays for it, a process we walk through in paying for a funeral with life insurance. With After, your family makes one call, and the transportation, the cremation and the services in the plan are already arranged.
- Where it's available. New York Life's AARP products have state limits, such as a $25,000 cap on guaranteed acceptance coverage in Minnesota, Missouri, Montana and Oregon, and agent-sold policies depend on what an agent can offer where you live. After provides cremation services only where it holds the required state licenses.
If you'd like to understand the mechanics before deciding anything, our guides to how prepaid cremation works, preneed funeral contracts and cremation insurance explain each option in plain terms.
Want the cremation itself arranged and paid for at today's price? See After's prepaid cremation plans or call 844-431-1320. Plans start as low as $25 a month, and there's no pressure to decide on the first call. We provide cremation services only where we hold the required state licenses (see our licenses).
New York Life FAQ
Is New York Life legit?
Yes. New York Life Insurance Company is a licensed mutual insurer that has operated since 1845 and holds an A++ financial strength rating from AM Best, as of August 1, 2025. Its Trustpilot score was 1.3 out of 5 on November 12, 2026, while NerdWallet reports fewer regulatory complaints than expected for its size.
Does New York Life have a waiting period?
New York Life's pages describe no waiting period on its agent-sold policies, which are underwritten before they are issued. AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life, which New York Life underwrites, pays a limited benefit of 110% of premiums paid for a death from natural causes in the first 2 years, and it pays the full benefit for accidental death from the first day.
How much does New York Life life insurance cost?
New York Life doesn't publish rates for agent-sold policies, so the cost comes from an agent's quote and depends on your age, gender, health and coverage amount. The AARP program publishes starting prices, such as $13 a month for $5,000 of permanent coverage for a 50-year-old woman who doesn't smoke, checked November 12, 2026.
Can I cancel a New York Life policy?
Yes. The AARP program's service pages describe a 30-day free look period during which you can cancel and have your premiums refunded. After that you can surrender a policy for any cash value it has built. The public pages don't list cancellation steps, so call New York Life at 1-800-CALL-NYL, or (800) 607-6957 for AARP program coverage.
Does New York Life life insurance pay for cremation?
New York Life pays cash to your beneficiary, who can use it for a cremation or for anything else. The policy doesn't arrange a cremation, choose a provider or lock in a price. If you want those things handled ahead of time, a prepaid cremation plan is built for that job.
What is the New York Life company?
New York Life is a mutual life insurance company, founded in 1845 and based in New York City, that is owned by its participating policy owners instead of shareholders. It sells life insurance through agents, underwrites the AARP Life Insurance Program, and offers group benefits through employers.
Why is New York Life insurance so expensive?
New York Life's whole life policies can cost more than term coverage or a small burial policy because they last for life, build cash value and are priced one person at a time through an agent. They are also eligible for dividends, which New York Life says aren't guaranteed, and the company doesn't publish rates you can compare in advance.
For more answers about planning ahead, see our pre-planning FAQs.
Ready to see what a plan costs? See After's prepaid cremation plans, compare prepaid cremation plan pricing, or call 844-431-1320 whenever you're ready. We provide cremation services only where we hold the required state licenses (see our licenses).
Sources
All sources accessed November 12, 2026, except the Choice Mutual and Washington State pages, which were accessed November 13, 2026.
- New York Life, home page: https://www.newyorklife.com/
- New York Life, Whole Life Insurance: https://www.newyorklife.com/products/insurance/whole-life
- New York Life, Term Life Insurance: https://www.newyorklife.com/products/insurance/term-life
- New York Life, Life Insurance overview: https://www.newyorklife.com/products/insurance/life-insurance
- New York Life, "How to calculate whole life insurance": https://www.newyorklife.com/articles/how-to-calculate-whole-life-insurance
- New York Life, Claims: https://www.newyorklife.com/claims
- New York Life, "New York Life Enters 2026 with Industry-Leading Financial Strength Ratings" (January 5, 2026): https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260105363269/en/
- AARP Life Insurance Program from New York Life: https://www.nylaarp.com/
- AARP Life Insurance Program, Level Benefit Term Life: https://www.nylaarp.com/life-insurance/term/protection
- AARP Life Insurance Program, Permanent Life: https://www.nylaarp.com/life-insurance/permanent
- AARP Life Insurance Program, Guaranteed Acceptance Life: https://www.nylaarp.com/life-insurance/guaranteed-life
- AARP Life Insurance Program, Guaranteed Acceptance Life FAQ: https://www.nylaarp.com/FAQ/Products/Guaranteed-Acceptance-Life/Guaranteed-Acceptance-Life-Insurance
- AARP Life Insurance Program, Contract management FAQ: https://www.nylaarp.com/FAQ/MyAccount/Contract-management/Contract-management
- Better Business Bureau, New York Life Insurance Company: https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/new-york/profile/insurance-companies/new-york-life-insurance-company-0121-349
- Trustpilot, New York Life: https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.newyorklife.com
- NerdWallet, New York Life Insurance Review (February 24, 2026): https://nerdwallet.com/insurance/life/new-york-life-insurance-review
- InvestmentNews, "The price of New York Life's 401(k) lawsuit: $19M" (February 27, 2024): https://www.investmentnews.com/retirement-planning/the-price-of-new-york-lifes-401k-lawsuit-19m/250057
- Choice Mutual, AARP life insurance review (modified July 1, 2026; rates retrieved March 9, 2026): https://choicemutual.com/life-insurance-reviews/aarp/
- Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner, "Kreidler fines NY Life Insurance Company $46,000 for training lapse" (March 4, 2024): https://insurance.wa.gov/news/kreidler-fines-ny-life-insurance-company-46000-training-lapse
- NAIC Consumer Information Source: https://content.naic.org/cis_consumer_information.htm
- After, Prepaid Cremation Plans: https://www.after.com/prearrange





