AARP life insurance review

(844) 717-5170(844) 760-0427
AARP life insurance review

AARP life insurance review

Our free guide allows you to create a custom end-of-life plan on your own terms.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
AARP life insurance review
AARP life insurance review

It pays to plan ahead
Preplan your own funeral arrangement online in minutes
See Pricing
Arrange Immediate
Cremation Services
Speak to our dedicated care specialists now
We're here to help 24/7
Call Us

Written by the After editorial team · Rates checked November 13, 2026 · Last updated November 13, 2026

After isn't affiliated with AARP and doesn't sell AARP policies. AARP is named for identification only.

Quick verdict: AARP life insurance is issued by New York Life, not by AARP, and you need an AARP membership to be covered. Members can choose term coverage that lasts to age 80, whole life with health questions, or guaranteed acceptance whole life with no health questions. Guaranteed acceptance pays limited benefits for the first 2 years.

People usually arrive at the AARP Life Insurance Program through a mailer or the member benefits page, and the first surprise is that AARP doesn't insure anyone itself. This review explains who stands behind the policies, what each product covers, what dated rate examples show by age, and how the ratings and complaint records stood on November 13, 2026. If your real goal is to have the cremation itself arranged and paid for, you can also look at After's prepaid cremation plans.

Who is AARP, and who issues the policies?

AARP is a membership organization for people 50 and older, founded in 1958 and based in Washington, DC, and it isn't an insurance company. Every policy in the AARP Life Insurance Program is underwritten by New York Life Insurance Company of New York, NY, which has been in business since 1845.

New York Life's program site states that "AARP and its affiliates are not insurers" and that New York Life pays royalty fees to AARP for the use of its intellectual property (nylaarp.com). The coverage is group insurance held in a trust that AARP set up for its members, which is why membership is required and why you receive a Certificate of Insurance in place of an individual policy.

In practical terms, AARP lends its name while New York Life sets the rates, decides who is approved, collects the premiums and pays the claims, so it is the company your family would call with a question or a claim. Its pages say that people who aren't AARP members yet can request a quote and join while they apply.

What does AARP sell to people over 50?

The AARP Life Insurance Program from New York Life sells 3 main products to members 50 and older: Level Benefit Term Life up to $150,000, Permanent Life up to $100,000, and Guaranteed Acceptance Life up to $30,000. None of them requires a medical exam, and only the guaranteed acceptance policy skips health questions entirely.

People also search for the two whole life products as AARP whole life insurance, AARP burial insurance and AARP final expense insurance. Our guides to burial insurance explained and burial insurance vs life insurance show how these policies differ.

Here is what New York Life's own pages said on November 13, 2026:

  • AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life (group whole life). Coverage runs up to $30,000 for AARP members ages 50 to 85 and their spouses or partners ages 45 to 85, with no health questions and no exam. In Guam, Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, Oregon and the U.S. Virgin Islands the limit is $25,000 and the ages stop at 80, in New York the ages are 50 to 75, and a footnote says the product isn't available in New Jersey. Benefits are limited for the first 2 years. Source: New York Life's Guaranteed Acceptance page.
  • AARP Permanent Life (group whole life with health questions). Coverage runs up to $100,000 for members ages 50 to 80 and spouses or partners ages 45 to 80. There is no exam, approval depends on the health information you provide, and the rate is guaranteed never to increase. Source: New York Life's Permanent Life page.
  • AARP Level Benefit Term Life. Coverage runs from $10,000 to $150,000 for members ages 50 to 74 and spouses or partners ages 45 to 74, and it can be kept until age 80. There is no exam, but there are health questions, and the rates aren't guaranteed and rise in 5-year age bands. Term coverage isn't available in New York or Montana. Source: New York Life's Level Benefit Term page.

Both whole life policies build cash value that you can borrow against, and both become "paid up" at age 95, after which no more premiums are due. A term policy can be exchanged for AARP Permanent Life at age 80 or earlier with no health questions, at a rate based on your age on the day you exchange.

How much does AARP cost by age?

AARP life insurance rates depend on your age, sex, tobacco use, state and coverage amount, and New York Life publishes only two starting figures for a 50-year-old woman who doesn't smoke: $11 a month for $10,000 of term coverage and $13 a month for $5,000 of Permanent Life. Everything else requires a personal quote.

Those starting rates appear on New York Life's term and permanent pages linked above. The program doesn't publish a rate chart by age, so the monthly prices below are a dated third-party example for $10,000 of coverage, as published by Choice Mutual, an independent agency whose page was updated July 1, 2026 and credits its own quote calculator with data retrieved March 9, 2026. They are not New York Life's current rates, and Choice Mutual earns commissions from other carriers, so read its comparisons with care.

AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life, $10,000:

  • Age 50: about $33 a month for a woman and $44 for a man
  • Age 60: about $44 a month for a woman and $60 for a man
  • Age 70: about $64 a month for a woman and $84 for a man
  • Age 80: about $112 a month for a woman and $144 for a man

AARP Permanent Life, $10,000:

  • Age 50: about $24 a month for a woman and $33 for a man
  • Age 60: about $36 a month for a woman and $50 for a man
  • Age 70: about $62 a month for a woman and $81 for a man
  • Age 80: about $92 a month for a woman and $122 for a man

Rates checked November 13, 2026. The same source shows $10,000 of Level Benefit Term at about $11 a month for a woman and $14 for a man at ages 50 to 54, rising to about $33 and $42 at ages 70 to 74. The pattern matters more than any single number, because answering health questions brings the price of whole life down at every age in these examples, while term starts out far less expensive, climbs every 5 years and ends at 80. Your own quote will depend on your state and your health, and our guide to what burial insurance costs covers the wider market.

Does AARP have a waiting period, and who qualifies?

Yes, on one product. AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life has a 2-year limited benefit period, during which a death from natural causes pays 110% of the premiums paid in most states, while an accidental death pays the full benefit from the first day. AARP Permanent Life and Level Benefit Term have no waiting period once you're approved.

Those terms come from New York Life's Guaranteed Acceptance FAQ, which also notes that Pennsylvania, Minnesota, Missouri and Montana use different first-2-year benefits. For the two products with health questions, New York Life's Permanent Life FAQ says the company can cancel coverage during the first 2 years if the enrollment form materially misstated your medical history.

It helps to know the three ways life insurance is usually approved:

  • Guaranteed issue asks no health questions and accepts everyone in the age range, and in exchange it limits the benefit for the first 2 years.
  • Simplified issue asks health questions with no exam, and people who are approved usually have full coverage from the first day, which is how AARP Permanent Life and Level Benefit Term work.
  • Fully underwritten coverage involves detailed questions and often an exam, and it rewards good health with the most coverage for each dollar.

To qualify, you need to be an AARP member or the spouse or partner of one, within the issue ages for the product, and living in a state where that product is sold.

What are the pros and cons of AARP?

The strengths of AARP life insurance are a top-rated issuer, a guaranteed acceptance option and whole life rates that never rise. The trade-offs are a 2-year limited benefit on the guaranteed policy, term rates that climb with age, and a membership requirement.

Pros

  • The issuer holds AM Best's highest rating. New York Life has an A++ (Superior) financial strength rating, affirmed in July 2026.
  • There is an option with no health questions. Guaranteed Acceptance Life accepts members 50 to 85 in most states for up to $30,000.
  • Whole life rates are locked. On Permanent Life and Guaranteed Acceptance Life, the rate is set by your age at application and never increases.
  • No exam, and 30 days to reconsider. None of the 3 products requires a medical exam, and you can return the certificate within 30 days for a refund of the premiums paid.

Cons

  • Guaranteed acceptance has a 2-year limited benefit. A death from natural causes in that window pays 110% of premiums in most states, not the face amount.
  • Term rates rise and coverage ends. Level Benefit Term rates aren't guaranteed, they increase in 5-year age bands, and the coverage stops at age 80 unless you exchange it.
  • Membership and state limits apply. You need an AARP membership, and term coverage isn't sold in New York or Montana.
  • Most rates aren't published. Beyond two starting figures, New York Life shows prices only after you request a quote.

Is AARP legit? Ratings, reviews and complaints

Yes. AARP is a long-established membership organization, and the AARP Life Insurance Program is underwritten by New York Life, a state-regulated insurer founded in 1845 that holds AM Best's highest financial strength rating. Complaint data reported by third parties runs below the industry norm, while customer review scores on open platforms are low.

The ratings that matter here belong to New York Life, and this is how they stood on November 13, 2026:

  • AM Best financial strength: A++ (Superior) with a stable outlook for New York Life Insurance Company, affirmed in an AM Best release dated July 23, 2026. This rating speaks to the insurer's ability to pay claims, not to customer service.
  • NAIC complaints: NerdWallet (updated February 24, 2026) reports that New York Life has drawn fewer complaints to state regulators than expected for a company of its size, and ValuePenguin (updated February 3, 2026) puts the figure at 27% as many complaints as a typical life insurer of its size. You can look up the current index on the NAIC consumer site, where 1.00 is the national median.
  • Better Business Bureau, New York Life: A+ rating, not accredited. Customer reviews on the profile average 1.09 out of 5 across about 250 reviews, with 284 complaints in the last 3 years and 52 in the last 12 months. Source: BBB profile.
  • Trustpilot: The program's own site, nylaarp.com, has no reviews. New York Life's profile shows a TrustScore of 1.3 out of 5 from 73 reviews, of which 86% are 1-star and 11% are 5-star, many of them about workplace disability claims.
  • Regulatory actions: The Washington state insurance commissioner announced on March 4, 2024 a $46,328 fine against New York Life for not verifying that 22 producers had completed required training before selling long-term care insurance. That action didn't involve the AARP program, and we found no state action from 2023 to 2026 aimed at the program.

What recent customers say

We looked for the most recent positive and negative reviews we could link to directly, and we show the same number of each. Only 2 five-star customer reviews posted since 2025 appear on New York Life's Trustpilot profile, so we show 2 of each instead of padding either side. Neither positive review names AARP, and the negatives are the 2 most recent that do.

  • Positive, March 1, 2026 (Trustpilot, 5 stars). John T. wrote that New York Life has always seemed to have his back, while adding that he hasn't needed to use the company in more than 20 years. Read the review.
  • Negative, September 28, 2026 (Trustpilot, 1 star). Cliff J. wrote that a family death benefit claim on a New York Life and AARP policy was denied as a lapse, and he disputes that the lapse notice was properly sent. Read the review.
  • Positive, August 20, 2025 (Trustpilot, 5 stars). Carlos O. praised the service he received, and said the attention felt personal and the solutions were fitted to his needs. Read the review.
  • Negative, May 27, 2026 (Trustpilot, 1 star). BethTotty W. wrote that she helped a hospice patient try to cancel a policy, and that the agent required full identity verification while the patient struggled to speak. Read the review.

Across the BBB and Trustpilot pages, the themes that come up most often in life insurance reviews are long waits on the phone, paperwork that customers say had to be sent more than once, and billing disputes after a policy change or cancellation. These are customers' own accounts.

Who is AARP a good fit for, and who should look elsewhere?

AARP life insurance from New York Life fits members 50 and older who want a familiar name, a highly rated insurer and a choice between health-question and guaranteed acceptance coverage. People who aren't members, or who want the arrangements themselves handled, usually have better-suited options. See every life insurance company we've reviewed to compare other companies.

AARP may fit if:

  • You're an AARP member and you want to choose between coverage with health questions and coverage that accepts everyone in the age range.
  • You want term coverage to age 80 that you can exchange for permanent coverage without new health questions.
  • You want AARP life insurance for seniors over 70, since Permanent Life accepts applicants to age 80 and Guaranteed Acceptance Life to age 85 in most states.

You may want to look elsewhere if:

  • You aren't an AARP member and don't want to join, because membership is required. New York Life, which issues the AARP policies, also sells its own coverage through agents, and Colonial Penn sells guaranteed acceptance coverage directly.
  • You live in New Jersey and need guaranteed acceptance coverage, or in New York or Montana and want term, because those products aren't offered there.
  • What you want most is for the cremation itself to be arranged and its price locked, so your family isn't left to plan and pay during the week they're grieving. Our guide to prepaid cremation plans for AARP members explains that option.

AARP vs a prepaid cremation plan: what's the difference?

AARP life insurance from New York Life pays your beneficiary a cash benefit, and your family then plans and pays for everything themselves. A prepaid cremation plan from After pays for the cremation services named in the plan, which are arranged ahead of time. Some families choose to have both.

  • What it pays. An AARP policy pays a fixed cash amount to your beneficiary, set on the day you buy. After's prepaid plan covers the cremation services in the plan, and an optional Memorial Fund can add a $1,000 to $2,500 cash benefit for a celebration of life (after.com/prearrange, checked November 12, 2026). For context, see the average cremation cost.
  • Price lock. Premiums on AARP's two whole life policies never increase, but the benefit doesn't rise with funeral prices, so the same check may cover less in 15 years than it would today. After's Crest and Summit plans list a price lock guarantee against price increases, and the Base plan doesn't include one.
  • Medical questions. AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life asks none, while Permanent Life and Level Benefit Term ask health questions. For After's plans, ask a Care Specialist which questions apply to you when you get your quote.
  • Waiting period. AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life has a 2-year limited benefit period, and the other two products have none once you're approved. After's explainer on whether a prepaid cremation plan is safe describes a standard 2-year contestable period on its plans and says that it isn't a waiting period.
  • What the family still has to do. With an AARP policy, your beneficiary files a claim with New York Life along with a certified death certificate, waits for the payment, and then chooses a provider, makes every arrangement and pays for it, as we explain in paying for a funeral with life insurance. With After, your family makes one call, and the transportation, the cremation and the services in the plan are already arranged.
  • Where it's available. New York Life says it is licensed in all 50 states, although the program's ages, coverage limits and products vary by state. After provides cremation services only where it holds the required state licenses.

Our guides to how prepaid cremation works, preneed funeral contracts and cremation insurance explain each option.

Want the cremation itself arranged and paid for at today's price? See After's prepaid cremation plans or call 844-431-1320. Plans start as low as $25 a month, and there's no pressure to decide on the first call. We provide cremation services only where we hold the required state licenses (see our licenses).

AARP FAQ

Is AARP legit?

Yes. AARP is a membership organization founded in 1958, and its life insurance program is underwritten by New York Life, which has operated since 1845 and holds an A++ (Superior) rating from AM Best.

Does AARP have a waiting period?

AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life has a 2-year limited benefit period. A death from natural causes in that window pays 110% of the premiums paid in most states, and an accidental death pays in full. AARP Permanent Life and Level Benefit Term have no waiting period once you're approved.

How much does AARP life insurance cost?

New York Life publishes starting rates of $11 a month for $10,000 of AARP term coverage and $13 a month for $5,000 of Permanent Life, both for a 50-year-old woman who doesn't smoke. Third-party examples from Choice Mutual, retrieved March 9, 2026, show $10,000 of Guaranteed Acceptance Life at about $33 a month for a 50-year-old woman and about $144 for an 80-year-old man.

Can I cancel an AARP policy?

Yes. New York Life gives you 30 days after you receive your Certificate of Insurance to return it for a refund of the premiums you've paid. After that you can still cancel, and New York Life says any cash value a whole life policy has built is yours to keep. The program's service line is 800-607-6957.

Does AARP life insurance pay for cremation?

An AARP policy pays cash to your beneficiary, who can use it for a cremation or for anything else. The policy doesn't arrange a cremation, choose a provider or lock in a price. If you want those handled ahead of time, a prepaid plan is built for that, and our guide asks is a prepaid cremation plan safe.

How should seniors compare life insurance companies?

Compare the same 4 things at every company: the coverage amount for your exact age, the monthly premium and whether it can rise, any waiting or limited benefit period, and the insurer's financial strength rating. Then check complaint records with the NAIC and your state insurance department.

How much is a $100,000 life insurance policy for seniors?

Through AARP, $100,000 is the online maximum for Permanent Life and Level Benefit Term goes to $150,000, but New York Life doesn't publish rates for those amounts, so you need a personal quote. Guaranteed Acceptance Life stops at $30,000.

At what age does AARP life insurance end?

AARP Level Benefit Term Life ends at age 80, although you can exchange it for AARP Permanent Life at or before that age without answering health questions. Permanent Life and Guaranteed Acceptance Life are whole life coverage that can last your entire life, and they become paid up at age 95.

What does $9.95 a month get you with Colonial Penn?

Colonial Penn is a separate insurer, and it doesn't issue AARP's coverage. According to Colonial Penn's own FAQ, $9.95 a month buys 1 unit of guaranteed acceptance whole life, and what a unit pays depends on your age, sex and state when you buy.

For more answers about planning ahead, see our pre-planning FAQs.

Ready to see what a plan costs? See After's prepaid cremation plans, compare prepaid cremation plan pricing, or call 844-431-1320 whenever you're ready. We provide cremation services only where we hold the required state licenses (see our licenses).

Sources

All sources accessed November 13, 2026, unless noted.

  • New York Life, AARP Life Insurance Program home page: https://www.nylaarp.com/
  • New York Life, AARP Guaranteed Acceptance Life Insurance: https://www.nylaarp.com/life-insurance/guaranteed-life/reasons-guaranteed
  • New York Life, Guaranteed Acceptance Life Insurance FAQ: https://www.nylaarp.com/FAQ/Products/Guaranteed-Acceptance-Life/Guaranteed-Acceptance-Life-Insurance
  • New York Life, AARP Permanent Life Insurance: https://www.nylaarp.com/life-insurance/permanent
  • New York Life, Permanent Life Insurance FAQ: https://www.nylaarp.com/FAQ/products/Permanent-Life/Permanent-Life-Insurance
  • New York Life, AARP Level Benefit Term Life Insurance: https://www.nylaarp.com/life-insurance/term/protection
  • New York Life, product comparison: https://nylaarp.com/compare
  • New York Life, Contract management FAQ: https://www.nylaarp.com/FAQ/MyAccount/Contract-management/Contract-management
  • New York Life, About: https://newyorklife.com/about
  • AARP, Guaranteed Acceptance Life Insurance from New York Life: https://www.aarp.org/membership/benefits/insurance/aarp-guaranteed-acceptance-life-insurance-from-new-york-life/
  • AM Best release on New York Life's ratings (July 23, 2026): https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260723355666/en/
  • Better Business Bureau, AARP (founding date and headquarters): https://www.bbb.org/us/dc/washington/profile/associations/aarp-0241-2126
  • Better Business Bureau, New York Life Insurance Company: https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/new-york/profile/insurance-companies/new-york-life-insurance-company-0121-349
  • Trustpilot, New York Life: https://www.trustpilot.com/review/newyorklife.com
  • Trustpilot, nylaarp.com: https://www.trustpilot.com/review/nylaarp.com
  • NerdWallet, AARP Life Insurance Review (updated February 24, 2026): https://www.nerdwallet.com/insurance/life/aarp-life-insurance-review
  • ValuePenguin, AARP Life Insurance Review (updated February 3, 2026): https://www.valuepenguin.com/life-insurance/aarp-review
  • Choice Mutual, AARP life insurance review (updated July 1, 2026; rate data retrieved March 9, 2026): https://choicemutual.com/life-insurance-reviews/aarp/
  • Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner, fine announcement (March 4, 2024): https://insurance.wa.gov/news/kreidler-fines-ny-life-insurance-company-46000-training-lapse
  • NAIC Consumer Information Source: https://content.naic.org/cis_consumer_information.htm
  • Colonial Penn, "How does Colonial Penn's $9.95 guaranteed acceptance whole life insurance work?" (accessed November 12, 2026): https://colonialpenn.com/service-support/faq/How-does-Colonial-Penns-$9.95-guaranteed-acceptance-whole-life-insurance-work
  • After, Prepaid Cremation Plans (accessed November 12, 2026): https://www.after.com/prearrange
We're here to help
Simple cremations. Upfront prices. Your way.

Save thousands compared to traditional funeral homes.

Arrange simple cremation services online in minutes

A dedicated care specialist to support you every step of the way.

We're here to help 24/7

Related posts

No items found.

Related posts

Call us