Physicians Mutual life insurance review

(844) 717-5170(844) 760-0427
Physicians Mutual life insurance review

Physicians Mutual life insurance review

Our free guide allows you to create a custom end-of-life plan on your own terms.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Physicians Mutual life insurance review
Physicians Mutual life insurance review

It pays to plan ahead
Preplan your own funeral arrangement online in minutes
See Pricing
Arrange Immediate
Cremation Services
Speak to our dedicated care specialists now
We're here to help 24/7
Call Us

Written by the After editorial team · Rates checked November 13, 2026 · Last updated November 13, 2026

After isn't affiliated with Physicians Mutual and doesn't sell Physicians Mutual policies. Physicians Mutual is named for identification only.

Quick verdict: Physicians Mutual's life policies are issued by Physicians Life Insurance Company, an Omaha insurer rated A+ by AM Best. Its main product for older buyers is Modified Whole Life, which asks no health questions and goes up to $30,000. The catch is a 2-year period in which a natural death returns premiums plus 10%, not the full benefit.

Most people know Physicians Mutual for dental and Medicare supplement coverage, but the same family of companies also sells life insurance directly to older adults. This review covers who issues those policies, what they cost at different ages according to Physicians Mutual's own published rate sheet, how the 2-year waiting period works, and how the ratings and customer reviews looked when we checked them on November 13, 2026. If your goal is to have the cremation itself arranged and paid for, see After's prepaid cremation plans.

Who is Physicians Mutual, and who issues the policies?

Physicians Mutual's life policies are issued by Physicians Life Insurance Company, which was formed in 1970 and is wholly owned by Physicians Mutual Insurance Company, founded in 1902. Both companies are based at 2600 Dodge Street in Omaha, Nebraska, and the group now sits under a mutual holding company called Physicians Mutual Holding Company.

Those details come from Physicians Mutual's About page and AM Best's November 13, 2025 announcement. The practical point for a buyer is that the company named on your life policy is Physicians Life Insurance Company, and that is the insurer that will pay the claim, so it is the name to look up when you check ratings or complaint records.

What does Physicians Mutual sell to people over 50?

Physicians Mutual sells two kinds of life insurance directly to older adults. Modified Whole Life is permanent coverage with no health questions and no medical exam, and Term Life is 10-year or 20-year coverage that asks health questions. Both are issued by Physicians Life Insurance Company, and the company also offers a children's whole life policy.

If you'd like the wider picture before comparing products, our guides to burial insurance explained and burial insurance vs life insurance explain how these policies differ. Here is what Physicians Mutual's own pages said on November 13, 2026:

  • Modified Whole Life Insurance. The Physicians Mutual life page says acceptance is guaranteed for people 45 to 85, with "no health questions and no medical exam," and coverage of up to $30,000. Its online quote tool offers amounts from $1,000 to $30,000.
  • What the rate sheet says. Physicians Mutual's downloadable life insurance rate sheet for the same policy (form L770) describes guaranteed acceptance from ages 35 to 85 and lists coverage of $5,000, $7,000, $10,000, $15,000 and $20,000, which is a narrower range than the website shows. The sheet's rates date from December 15, 2023, so treat the website as the more current guide.
  • Term Life Insurance. The same rate sheet lists 10-year and 20-year term policies (form L760) with $25,000 or $50,000 of coverage. Approval depends on "the answers to the health questions" in the application, and the published age bands run through 70 for 10-year terms and through 60 for 20-year terms, so term coverage isn't an option for most people already in their 70s.

For most readers, the product that matters is Modified Whole Life, which is built for older buyers who want a modest permanent policy.

How much does Physicians Mutual cost by age?

Physicians Mutual does publish monthly rates for its Modified Whole Life policy. On its downloadable rate sheet, $10,000 of coverage runs from $39.20 a month for a 50-year-old man to $141.20 a month for an 80-year-old man, with lower rates for women. Those rates took effect December 15, 2023, and the sheet says they are subject to change.

The figures below are monthly bank-draft rates for Modified Whole Life, copied from Physicians Mutual's rate sheet in the version we opened for Ohio.

  • Age 50: $10,000 costs $39.20 a month for a man and $33.20 for a woman, and $5,000 costs $20.10 for a man and $17.10 for a woman.
  • Age 60: $10,000 costs $49.60 a month for a man and $41.20 for a woman, and $5,000 costs $25.30 for a man and $21.10 for a woman.
  • Age 70: $10,000 costs $75.40 a month for a man and $61.20 for a woman, and $5,000 costs $38.20 for a man and $31.10 for a woman.
  • Age 80: $10,000 costs $141.20 a month for a man and $119.60 for a woman, and $5,000 costs $71.10 for a man and $60.30 for a woman.

Rates checked November 13, 2026, from Physicians Mutual's published rate sheet (rates effective December 15, 2023, Ohio version, monthly bank draft). Your price depends on your age, sex, state, coverage amount and payment method, so ask Physicians Mutual for a current quote.

The pattern is the one you'll see with any policy that skips health questions, which is that the monthly price climbs quickly with age. An 80-year-old man pays a little more than 3.5 times what a 50-year-old man pays for the same $10,000, and over 10 years of premiums at age 80 he would pay about $16,944, which is more than the policy's face amount. For a wider sense of the market, see what burial insurance costs.

Does Physicians Mutual have a waiting period, and who qualifies?

Yes. Physicians Mutual's Modified Whole Life policy has a 2-year modified benefit. Its rate sheet says that if you die of natural causes in the first 2 years, your beneficiary receives all the premiums you paid plus an extra 10%. Accidental death pays the full benefit from the first day, and after 2 years the full benefit is paid for death from any cause.

The exact wording on Physicians Mutual's rate sheet is that for a death that isn't accidental during the first 2 years, your beneficiary "receives all the premiums you've paid plus an extra 10%," and that after 2 years "the full benefit amount (less any indebtedness) is paid for death from any cause." The company's life insurance FAQ explains the general rule behind this, saying that guaranteed acceptance coverage "likely has a limited benefit period" while underwritten policies don't have a waiting period before benefits are paid.

It helps to know the three ways life insurance is usually approved, since that choice decides whether a waiting period applies:

  • Guaranteed issue asks no health questions and accepts everyone in the age range, and in exchange it limits the benefit for the first 2 years, which is how Physicians Mutual's Modified Whole Life works.
  • Simplified issue asks a short list of health questions with no exam, and people who qualify usually get the full benefit from the first day.
  • Fully underwritten coverage involves detailed questions and often an exam, and it rewards good health with the most coverage for each dollar, which is closer to how Physicians Mutual's term policies are approved.

On qualifying, the website describes guaranteed acceptance for people 45 to 85, and there is no membership requirement. Physicians Mutual's pages don't list the states where the life policies are sold, so ask on the call whether the policy and the amount you want are available where you live.

What are the pros and cons of Physicians Mutual?

Physicians Mutual's strengths are an A+ financial strength rating, guaranteed acceptance with no health questions, and rates the company publishes. Its trade-offs are a 2-year modified benefit for natural death, a modest coverage ceiling and premiums that climb steeply for people who buy in their late 70s or 80s.

Pros

  • Strong financial strength rating. AM Best upgraded Physicians Life Insurance Company and Physicians Mutual Insurance Company to A+ (Superior) with a stable outlook on November 13, 2025.
  • Acceptance is guaranteed. Modified Whole Life asks no health questions and requires no medical exam for people within the published age range.
  • Rates are published. Physicians Mutual posts a downloadable rate sheet by age, sex and coverage amount, which makes comparison easier than with insurers that only quote by phone.
  • Accidents are covered in full from day one, with a 31-day review. An accidental death pays the full benefit right away, and the rate sheet gives a 31-day risk-free review with a full premium refund if you cancel.

Cons

  • The full benefit for natural death waits 2 years. A death from illness in that window returns premiums plus 10%, not the face amount.
  • Coverage is modest. The website caps Modified Whole Life at $30,000, and the published rate sheet tops out at $20,000.
  • Premiums rise steeply with age. On the published sheet, $10,000 costs $39.20 a month for a 50-year-old man and $141.20 a month for an 80-year-old man.
  • Canceling takes a written request. Physicians Mutual's FAQ says cancellation requests "must be sent in writing," which several customers mention in reviews.

Is Physicians Mutual legit? Ratings, reviews and complaints

Yes, Physicians Mutual is a legitimate, state-regulated insurance group that has operated in Omaha since 1902, and its life insurer holds an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best. Customer reviews are mixed, with a 3.9 TrustScore on Trustpilot and a low average on the Better Business Bureau, and most posted reviews concern dental and Medicare supplement coverage rather than life insurance.

Here is how the numbers stood when we checked them on November 13, 2026:

  • AM Best financial strength: A+ (Superior) with a stable outlook for both Physicians Life Insurance Company and Physicians Mutual Insurance Company, upgraded from A (Excellent) on November 13, 2025, per AM Best's announcement on Business Wire. This rating speaks to the ability to pay claims, not to customer service.
  • Better Business Bureau: A+ rating and accredited. Customer reviews on the profile average 1.27 out of 5 across 56 reviews. Source: BBB customer reviews page. The BBB letter grade reflects how a business responds to complaints, which is why it can sit beside a low customer score.
  • Trustpilot: TrustScore of 3.9 out of 5 from 208 reviews, with 51% at 5 stars and 23% at 1 star. Trustpilot shows that Physicians Mutual replied to 93% of negative reviews and that it invites customers to leave reviews. Source: Trustpilot.
  • NAIC complaints: We couldn't confirm a current complaint index for Physicians Life Insurance Company from a source we could read. You can look it up on the NAIC consumer site by searching the company's name, where 1.00 is the national median.
  • Regulatory actions: We found no state insurance department action or lawsuit involving Physicians Life Insurance Company's life policies from 2023 to 2026 in the sources we reviewed.

What recent customers say

We looked for the most recent positive and negative reviews we could link to directly, and we show the same number of each. Almost every recent review we found is about Physicians Mutual's dental or Medicare supplement coverage, because few customers post about life policies, so read these as a picture of the company's service in general rather than of its life insurance.

  • Positive, November 13, 2026 (Trustpilot, 5 stars). Eric C. wrote that doing business with the company's dental coverage has been a good experience and that solid coverage matters when the time comes. Read the review.
  • Negative, November 13, 2026 (Trustpilot, 2 stars). John B. wrote that his rates went up significantly with no improvement he could see in his dental coverage, and that he couldn't find what his extended rider covered. Read the review.
  • Positive, November 12, 2026 (Trustpilot, 5 stars). Donald B. said he was pleased with the payments, the customer service and how promptly his matters were handled. Read the review.
  • Negative, November 11, 2026 (Trustpilot, 1 star). Susan C. wrote that she wasn't sure what, if anything, had been paid on her dental bills, and the company replied asking her to call so it could look into it. Read the review.
  • Positive, November 12, 2026 (Trustpilot, 5 stars). Hubert S. described the service he received as on time, friendly and courteous, and called it "Friendly and reliable." Read the review.
  • Negative, November 10, 2026 (Trustpilot, 2 stars). Linda L. questioned the value of the company's top dental plan, which she said costs almost $60 a month. Read the review.

On the BBB profile, the complaint themes that come up most often in customers' own accounts are premium increases on dental and supplemental plans, claims that customers say were denied or slow, and cancellations that had to be sent by mail. The written cancellation rule applies to life coverage too, so it's worth knowing before you buy.

Who is Physicians Mutual a good fit for, and who should look elsewhere?

Physicians Mutual's Modified Whole Life fits people roughly 45 to 85 who can't qualify for coverage that asks health questions and who want a small permanent policy from a highly rated insurer with published prices. People in good health, people who need more than $30,000, and people who want the arrangements themselves handled usually have better-suited options. To see the other insurers we've reviewed, grouped by policy type, visit our life insurance reviews hub.

Physicians Mutual may fit if:

  • You have a health condition that would likely get you declined for a policy with health questions, and you want certainty of acceptance from an insurer with an A+ rating. Gerber Life and Colonial Penn also sell whole life with no health questions.
  • You are under 70 and in good health, and a 10-year term policy of $25,000 or $50,000 would cover a specific need such as a remaining mortgage.

You may want to look elsewhere if:

  • You are older than 85, or younger than 45 and looking for guaranteed acceptance, because those ages fall outside the range on Physicians Mutual's life page.
  • What you want most is for the cremation itself to be arranged and its price locked, so your family isn't left to plan and pay in the same week they are grieving.

Physicians Mutual vs a prepaid cremation plan: what's the difference?

Physicians Mutual pays your beneficiary a cash benefit, and your family then plans and pays for everything themselves. A prepaid cremation plan from After pays for the cremation services named in the plan, which are arranged ahead of time. Life insurance pays money and a prepaid plan pays for the service, and some families choose to have both.

  • What it pays. Physicians Mutual pays a fixed cash amount to your beneficiary, set on the day you buy. After's prepaid plan covers the cremation services in the plan, and an optional Memorial Fund can add a $1,000 to $2,500 cash benefit for a celebration of life (after.com/prearrange, checked November 12, 2026). For context on what a cremation runs today, see the average cremation cost.
  • Price lock. Physicians Mutual's whole life premium is level, but the benefit doesn't rise with funeral prices, so the same check may cover less in 15 years than it would today. After's Crest and Summit plans list a price lock guarantee against price increases, and the Base plan doesn't include one.
  • Medical questions. Physicians Mutual's Modified Whole Life asks none, while its term policies do. For After's plans, ask a Care Specialist which questions apply to you when you get your quote.
  • Waiting period. Physicians Mutual's Modified Whole Life returns premiums plus 10% for a natural death in the first 2 years. After's explainer on whether a prepaid cremation plan is safe describes a standard 2-year contestable period on its plans and says that it isn't a waiting period.
  • What the family still has to do. With Physicians Mutual, your family files a claim with a certified death certificate, waits for the payment, and then chooses a provider, makes every arrangement and pays for it, a process we walk through in paying for a funeral with life insurance. With After, your family makes one call, and the transportation, the cremation and the services in the plan are already arranged.
  • Where it's available. Physicians Mutual's life pages don't list the states where its policies are sold, so check availability on a call. After provides cremation services only where it holds the required state licenses.

If you'd like to understand the mechanics before deciding anything, our guides to how prepaid cremation works, preneed funeral contracts and cremation insurance explain each option in plain terms.

Want the cremation itself arranged and paid for at today's price? See After's prepaid cremation plans or call 844-431-1320. Plans start as low as $25 a month, and there's no pressure to decide on the first call. We provide cremation services only where we hold the required state licenses (see our licenses).

Physicians Mutual FAQ

Is Physicians Mutual legit?

Yes. Physicians Mutual has operated in Omaha since 1902, and its life policies are issued by Physicians Life Insurance Company, which AM Best rates A+ (Superior) as of its November 13, 2025 upgrade. Customer reviews are mixed, with a 3.9 TrustScore on Trustpilot and a 1.27 average on the BBB as of November 13, 2026, and most of those reviews concern dental and Medicare supplement plans.

Does Physicians Mutual have a waiting period?

Yes, on its Modified Whole Life policy. Physicians Mutual's rate sheet says a death from natural causes in the first 2 years pays back all premiums paid plus 10%, while an accidental death pays the full benefit from the first day. After 2 years, the full benefit is paid for death from any cause.

How much does Physicians Mutual life insurance cost?

Physicians Mutual's published rate sheet, with rates effective December 15, 2023, lists $10,000 of Modified Whole Life at $39.20 a month for a 50-year-old man and $33.20 for a 50-year-old woman, rising to $141.20 and $119.60 at age 80. Rates vary by state and may have changed, so ask for a current quote.

Can I cancel a Physicians Mutual policy?

Yes. Physicians Mutual's rate sheet gives a 31-day risk-free review, and if you cancel within those 31 days you get a full refund of the premium you paid. After that you can still cancel at any time, but Physicians Mutual's FAQ says the request must be sent in writing, and its service line is 1-800-228-9100.

Does Physicians Mutual life insurance pay for cremation?

Physicians Mutual pays cash to your beneficiary, who can use it for a cremation or for anything else. The policy doesn't arrange a cremation, choose a provider or lock in a price. If you want those things handled ahead of time, a prepaid cremation plan is built for that job.

Is Physicians Mutual a reputable insurance company?

Physicians Mutual is a long-established insurer with an A+ (Superior) financial strength rating from AM Best and an A+ grade from the BBB. Its customer review scores are mixed, so it's worth reading the policy terms, especially the 2-year modified benefit and the written cancellation rule, before you sign.

For more answers about planning ahead, see our pre-planning FAQs.

Ready to see what a plan costs? See After's prepaid cremation plans, compare prepaid cremation plan pricing, or call 844-431-1320 whenever you're ready. We provide cremation services only where we hold the required state licenses (see our licenses).

Sources

All sources accessed November 13, 2026, except the After page, which was checked November 12, 2026.

  • Physicians Mutual, About: https://www.physiciansmutual.com/about
  • Physicians Mutual, Life Insurance: https://physiciansmutual.com/web/life
  • Physicians Mutual, Life Insurance FAQs: https://physiciansmutual.com/web/life/faqs
  • Physicians Mutual, Life insurance rate sheet LIFE_PDF_RC01_0424 (rates effective December 15, 2023, Ohio version): https://www.physiciansmutual.com/web/api/doc/LIFE_PDF_RC01_0424?state=OH
  • AM Best via Business Wire, "AM Best Upgrades Credit Ratings of Physicians Mutual Group Members" (November 13, 2025): https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20251113643602/en/AM-Best-Upgrades-Credit-Ratings-of-Physicians-Mutual-Group-Members
  • Better Business Bureau, Physicians Mutual Insurance Company customer reviews: https://www.bbb.org/us/ne/omaha/profile/insurance-companies/physicians-mutual-insurance-company-0714-104000372/customer-reviews
  • Trustpilot, Physicians Mutual: https://www.trustpilot.com/review/physiciansmutual.com
  • NAIC Consumer Information Source: https://content.naic.org/cis_consumer_information.htm
  • After, Prepaid Cremation Plans: https://www.after.com/prearrange
We're here to help
Simple cremations. Upfront prices. Your way.

Save thousands compared to traditional funeral homes.

Arrange simple cremation services online in minutes

A dedicated care specialist to support you every step of the way.

We're here to help 24/7

Related posts

No items found.

Related posts

Call us