
It pays to plan ahead
Preplan your own funeral arrangement online in minutes
Arrange Immediate
Cremation Services
Cremation Services
Speak to our dedicated care specialists now
We're here to help 24/7
Call Us
Written by the After editorial team · Rates checked November 13, 2026 · Last updated November 13, 2026
After isn't affiliated with Foresters and doesn't sell Foresters policies. Foresters is named for identification only.
Quick verdict: Foresters Financial is a fraternal benefit society, and its final expense policy, PlanRight Whole Life, is issued by The Independent Order of Foresters to people 50 to 85. It asks health questions but needs no exam, pays the full benefit from day one on two of its three plans, and doesn't publish rates online.
Most people meet Foresters through an agent who suggests a small whole life policy for a funeral or cremation, and this review covers what that policy pays, using Foresters' own terms, its ratings and complaint records as of November 13, 2026, and an even number of recent customer reviews from each side. If your goal is to have the cremation itself arranged and paid for, rather than leaving your family a check to turn into arrangements, see After's prepaid cremation plans.
Who is Foresters, and who issues the policies?
Foresters Financial is the trade name of The Independent Order of Foresters, a fraternal benefit society founded in 1874 and headquartered in Toronto, Canada, which issues its own US life insurance through its US branch. Foresters says it serves 2.6 million members and clients across Canada, the United States and the United Kingdom.
A fraternal benefit society is a member-owned, nonprofit organization that sells life insurance to its members and puts part of its surplus back into member benefits and community programs. Buying a Foresters policy makes you a member, and the policy is called a "certificate," although it works the same way for your family.
Foresters' PlanRight page states that its products "are underwritten by The Independent Order of Foresters," and its June 17, 2024 anniversary release confirms the 1874 founding.
What does Foresters sell to people over 50?
Foresters' main product for people over 50 is PlanRight Whole Life, a final expense policy for ages 50 to 85 with $5,000 to $35,000 of coverage, no medical exam and three plan levels set by your answers to health questions. Foresters also sells term, universal and other whole life policies, mostly for younger buyers or larger amounts.
If you'd like the wider picture before comparing, our guide to burial insurance vs life insurance explains how small final expense policies differ from traditional coverage. Here is what Foresters' own pages and its PlanRight product guide (form 503306 US, dated April 2025) said on November 13, 2026:
- PlanRight Whole Life (Foresters' final expense policy). Issue ages are 50 to 85, and coverage runs from $5,000 to $35,000. It is simplified issue, which Foresters describes as needing no bloodwork, saliva swab or paramedical visit, and the premiums are guaranteed level with coverage lasting to age 121. Source: Foresters' PlanRight page.
- The three PlanRight plans. Preferred is open to ages 50 to 85 with up to $35,000 of coverage through age 80 and $15,000 from 81 to 85. Standard covers the same ages with up to $20,000 through age 80 and $10,000 after. Basic is for ages 50 to 80 only, with up to $15,000. Source: PlanRight product guide.
- Riders at no added premium. Every PlanRight plan includes a Common Carrier Accidental Death Rider and a Family Health Benefit Rider, which pays up to $650 per person for certain natural disaster expenses, and Preferred and Standard add a terminal illness rider that lets you take up to 95% of the benefit early.
- Cash value. PlanRight builds guaranteed cash value that you can borrow against, and any unpaid loan and interest come out of the death benefit.
- Strong Foundation Term. A non-medical term policy for ages 18 to 80 with $50,000 to $500,000 of coverage and 10 to 30 year terms. Source: Foresters' Strong Foundation page.
- Member benefits. Members can use LawAssure for online wills and powers of attorney, member discounts, scholarships and community grants, and certificates of $10,000 or more qualify for an orphan benefit and an interest-free terminal illness loan. Foresters states these benefits are "non-contractual" and can change. Source: Foresters member benefits.
PlanRight is sold through licensed agents, not an online application.
How much does Foresters cost by age?
Foresters doesn't publish PlanRight rates, so there is no official price for a 60-year-old or a 75-year-old on foresters.com. Quotes come from a licensed agent, and the price depends on your age, sex, tobacco use, coverage amount and which of the three PlanRight plans your health answers place you in.
Neither Foresters' PlanRight page nor its product guide listed premiums on November 13, 2026, so we have left prices out instead of guessing. Rates checked November 13, 2026. These are the factors that move a quote, based on Foresters' product guide:
- Age. The older you are on the day the certificate is issued, the higher the monthly premium for the same coverage, and after age 80 the maximum coverage drops.
- Health answers. Your answers decide whether you qualify for Preferred, Standard or Basic, and Basic carries a limited benefit for the first 2 years.
- Tobacco. Foresters sorts applicants into tobacco and non-tobacco classes, and tobacco users pay more.
- Coverage amount. PlanRight starts at $5,000, and the premium rises with each thousand dollars of coverage you add.
When you get a quote, ask the agent for the premium in writing and which PlanRight plan you were placed in. For a sense of what similar policies cost across the market, see what burial insurance costs.
Does Foresters have a waiting period, and who qualifies?
It depends on the plan. Foresters' PlanRight Preferred and Standard plans pay 100% of the face amount from the first day, with no waiting period. The PlanRight Basic plan has a 2-year graded benefit, so a death from natural causes in those 2 years returns the premiums paid plus 10% annual interest.
Foresters' product guide says that on the Basic plan an accidental death during the first 2 years pays the full face amount, and that from the third year on, the full benefit is paid for any cause of death (PlanRight product guide). Every life policy also has a 2-year contestable period, and Foresters' claim pages say that if someone dies within 2 years of the issue date, the company will ask for medical records before paying, which can slow a claim even when the full benefit applies.
It helps to know the three ways life insurance is usually approved:
- Guaranteed issue asks no health questions and accepts everyone in the age range, and in exchange it limits the benefit for the first 2 or 3 years. Foresters doesn't offer a guaranteed issue final expense policy.
- Simplified issue asks a list of health questions with no exam, and people who qualify often get full coverage from the first day, which is how PlanRight works.
- Fully underwritten coverage involves detailed questions and often an exam, and it rewards good health with the most coverage for each dollar.
To qualify for any PlanRight plan, you must be 50 to 85 (50 to 80 for Basic), live in the United States and answer "no" to the first 6 medical questions on the application, and your height and weight must fit Foresters' guidelines. Foresters' page says PlanRight is "Not for use in Oregon" and may not be approved in every state, and buying a certificate automatically makes you a Foresters member.
What are the pros and cons of Foresters?
Foresters' strengths are full coverage from day one for people healthy enough to qualify for its Preferred or Standard plans, level premiums for life and riders included at no added cost. Its trade-offs are a graded benefit on the Basic plan, no guaranteed issue option and no published rates. Each point below ties back to a fact above.
Pros
- No medical exam. PlanRight is simplified issue for ages 50 to 85, with no bloodwork, swabs or nurse visit, just health questions and database checks.
- Full benefit from the first day on two plans. PlanRight Preferred and Standard pay 100% of the face amount from day one, according to Foresters' product guide.
- Level premiums and lifetime coverage. Premiums are guaranteed not to rise, coverage lasts to age 121 and the certificate builds cash value.
- Riders and member benefits at no added premium. Every plan includes a common carrier accidental death rider and a family health benefit rider, and members can use LawAssure for wills along with other non-contractual benefits.
Cons
- A 2-year graded benefit on Basic. If your health answers place you in the Basic plan, a death from natural causes in the first 2 years returns premiums plus 10% interest rather than the face amount.
- No guaranteed issue option. A "yes" to any of the first 6 medical questions means you can't get PlanRight at all, so people with serious health conditions need another option.
- Rates aren't published. You need an agent's quote to learn what PlanRight costs, which makes it slower to compare side by side.
- Coverage limits narrow with age and state. Coverage tops out at $35,000, drops to $15,000 or less after age 80, Basic stops at 80, and PlanRight isn't sold in Oregon.
Is Foresters legit? Ratings, reviews and complaints
Yes, Foresters is a legitimate, state-regulated fraternal insurer that has operated since 1874, and The Independent Order of Foresters holds an A (Excellent) financial strength rating from AM Best. Its US customer service record is weaker, with a D- grade from the Better Business Bureau and NAIC complaint data reported above the expected level.
Here is how the numbers stood when we checked them on November 13, 2026:
- AM Best financial strength: A (Excellent) with a stable outlook for The Independent Order of Foresters, assigned October 10, 2025, according to Foresters' financial strength page. This rating speaks to the company's ability to pay claims, not to customer service.
- Better Business Bureau: D- rating and not accredited, for Foresters Financial Holding Company, Inc. in New York. BBB lists "Failure to respond to 21 complaint(s)" as the main reason, along with 24 complaints in the last 3 years and 6 in the last 12 months. Customer reviews on the same profile average 1.24 out of 5 across 17 reviews. Source: BBB profile.
- Trustpilot: TrustScore of 4.6 out of 5 from about 1,150 reviews, with 82% at 5 stars and 16% at 1 star. Almost all of the recent reviews we read came from UK customers writing about savings and child trust fund accounts rather than US life insurance, so this score says little about PlanRight. Source: Trustpilot.
- NAIC complaints: NerdWallet's review, dated February 24, 2026, reports that Foresters drew more than the expected number of complaints to state regulators over 3 years, based on National Association of Insurance Commissioners data. You can look up the current complaint index yourself on the NAIC consumer site, where 1.00 is the national median.
- Regulatory actions: We found no state insurance department action or lawsuit from 2023 to 2026 in the sources we reviewed.
What recent customers say
We looked for the most recent positive and negative reviews from US customers that we could link to, and we show the same number of each. Recent positive reviews on Trustpilot are almost all from the UK side of the business, and the only US positive review we found on BBB was posted in April 2025, so we are showing 1 of each instead of padding either side.
- Positive, April 12, 2025 (BBB, 5 stars). John S. wrote that Foresters had taken good care of him, in one of the few favorable reviews on the company's BBB profile. Read the review.
- Negative, October 19, 2026 (Trustpilot, 1 star). Gary, a US reviewer who gave only his first name, wrote that he waited on hold and found Foresters slow to respond to him. Read the review.
Across the US reviews on the BBB profile, the themes that come up most often are cancellations that customers say took weeks or months and death claims they describe as slow because of repeated document requests. These are customers' own accounts, and they are a good reason to keep copies of every form you send.
Who is Foresters a good fit for, and who should look elsewhere?
Foresters fits people 50 to 85 in reasonably good health who want a small whole life policy with level premiums and full coverage from the first day, and who are comfortable buying through an agent. People with serious health conditions, people in Oregon and people who want the arrangements themselves handled usually have better-suited options. You'll find the rest in our full list of life insurance reviews.
Foresters may fit if:
- You can answer "no" to PlanRight's health questions, so you are likely to qualify for the Preferred or Standard plan and avoid a waiting period.
- You want a fixed premium for life, a modest amount of coverage between $5,000 and $35,000, and extras such as online will preparation through Foresters' member benefits. Royal Neighbors of America is another fraternal benefit society that sells final expense whole life.
You may want to look elsewhere if:
- You have a health condition that would mean a "yes" to one of the first 6 medical questions, because Foresters has no guaranteed issue policy to fall back on. Gerber Life and American General both sell guaranteed issue policies.
- You are over 85, live in Oregon or want to compare published prices online before you talk to anyone.
- What you want most is for the cremation itself to be arranged and its price locked, so your family isn't left to plan and pay in the same week they are grieving. Our guide to burial insurance explained covers the difference.
Foresters vs a prepaid cremation plan: what's the difference?
Foresters pays your beneficiary a cash benefit, and your family then plans and pays for everything themselves. A prepaid cremation plan from After pays for the cremation services named in the plan, which are arranged ahead of time. Life insurance pays money and a prepaid plan pays for the service, and some families choose to have both.
- What it pays. Foresters pays a fixed cash amount to your beneficiary, set on the day you buy. After's prepaid plan covers the cremation services in the plan, and an optional Memorial Fund can add a $1,000 to $2,500 cash benefit for a celebration of life (after.com/prearrange, checked November 12, 2026). For context on what a cremation runs today, see the average cremation cost.
- Price lock. Foresters' premium is level, but the benefit doesn't rise with funeral prices, so the same check may cover less in 15 years than it would today. After's Crest and Summit plans list a price lock guarantee against price increases, and the Base plan doesn't include one.
- Medical questions. Foresters' PlanRight asks health questions and checks medical and prescription databases. For After's plans, ask a Care Specialist which questions apply to you when you get your quote.
- Waiting period. Foresters' Preferred and Standard plans have none, and the Basic plan has a 2-year graded benefit. After's explainer on whether a prepaid cremation plan is safe describes a standard 2-year contestable period on its plans and says that it isn't a waiting period.
- What the family still has to do. With Foresters, your family files a claim with a certified death certificate, waits for the check to arrive by mail, and then chooses a provider, makes every arrangement and pays for it, a process we walk through in paying for a funeral with life insurance. With After, your family makes one call, and the transportation, the cremation and the services in the plan are already arranged.
- Where it's available. Foresters sells PlanRight in most states, but not in Oregon. After provides cremation services only where it holds the required state licenses.
If you'd like to understand the mechanics before deciding anything, our guides to how prepaid cremation works, preneed funeral contracts and cremation insurance explain each option in plain terms.
Want the cremation itself arranged and paid for at today's price? See After's prepaid cremation plans or call 844-431-1320. Plans start as low as $25 a month, and there's no pressure to decide on the first call. We provide cremation services only where we hold the required state licenses (see our licenses).
Foresters FAQ
Is Foresters legit?
Yes. Foresters Financial is the trade name of The Independent Order of Foresters, a fraternal benefit society founded in 1874 that holds an A (Excellent) financial strength rating from AM Best. Its US customer service record is weaker, with a D- grade from the BBB as of November 13, 2026, so read the certificate terms carefully before you buy.
Does Foresters have a waiting period?
Foresters' PlanRight Preferred and Standard plans have no waiting period and pay the full benefit from the first day. The PlanRight Basic plan has a 2-year graded benefit, during which a death from natural causes returns premiums plus 10% annual interest and an accidental death pays the full face amount.
How much does Foresters life insurance cost?
Foresters doesn't publish PlanRight rates on its website, so prices come only from a quote through a licensed agent. Your premium depends on your age, sex, tobacco use, coverage amount and which of the three PlanRight plans your health answers qualify you for. Rates checked November 13, 2026.
Can I cancel a Foresters policy?
Yes. Foresters' customer care page says you can return a newly issued contract, or send a signed cancellation request, within 10 days of receiving it. After that you can cancel by completing Foresters' Surrender Form and sending it to Policy Administration, and you may receive any cash value the certificate has built.
Does Foresters life insurance pay for cremation?
Foresters pays cash to your beneficiary, who can use it for a cremation or anything else, but the certificate doesn't arrange a cremation or lock in a price. If you want that handled ahead of time, After's prepaid cremation plans are built for that job.
How can I check whether a life insurance company is financially strong?
Start with the AM Best rating of the company that actually issues the policy, then check its complaint index on the NAIC consumer site and confirm with your state insurance department that it is licensed where you live.
How long do foresters take to pay out?
Foresters doesn't publish a payout timeline. Its customer care page says claims can be filed online through MyClaims, by email or by mail, and that approved benefits are paid by check mailed to the beneficiary. Claims within 2 years of the issue date require medical records, which can add time.
Is Foresters financially trustworthy?
The Independent Order of Foresters holds an A (Excellent) financial strength rating from AM Best with a stable outlook, assigned October 10, 2025, which speaks to its ability to pay claims rather than to its customer service.
What is Foresters Life Insurance's rating on the BBB?
Foresters Financial Holding Company, Inc. had a D- rating from the Better Business Bureau on November 13, 2026, and it isn't BBB accredited. BBB lists failure to respond to 21 complaints as the main reason, and customer reviews on the profile average 1.24 out of 5.
For more answers about planning ahead, see our pre-planning FAQs.
Ready to see what a plan costs? See After's prepaid cremation plans, compare prepaid cremation plan pricing, or call 844-431-1320 whenever you're ready. We provide cremation services only where we hold the required state licenses (see our licenses).
Sources
All sources accessed November 13, 2026.
- Foresters, PlanRight Whole Life Insurance: https://www.foresters.com/en/life-insurance/whole-life-insurance/planright
- Foresters, PlanRight Product Guide (form 503306 US, April 2025): https://ezbiz.foresters.com/foresters-planright-product-guide
- Foresters, Strong Foundation Term: https://www.foresters.com/en/life-insurance/term-life-insurance/strong-foundation-term
- Foresters, Member Benefits: https://www.foresters.com/en/member-benefits
- Foresters, Customer Care: https://www.foresters.com/en/customer-care
- Foresters, "Foresters Financial celebrates 150 years of protecting families" (June 17, 2024): https://www.foresters.com/en/about-us/newsroom/news-releases/foresters-financial-celebrates-150-years-of-protecting-families
- Foresters, Financial Strength: https://www.foresters.com/en-ca/about-us/financial-strength
- Better Business Bureau, Foresters Financial Holding Company, Inc.: https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/new-york/profile/investment-management/foresters-financial-holding-company-inc-0121-2549
- Better Business Bureau, Foresters customer reviews: https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/new-york/profile/investment-management/foresters-financial-holding-company-inc-0121-2549/customer-reviews
- Trustpilot, Foresters Financial: https://www.trustpilot.com/review/foresters.com
- NerdWallet, Foresters Life Insurance Review (February 24, 2026): https://www.nerdwallet.com/p/reviews/insurance/foresters-life-insurance
- NAIC Consumer Information Source: https://content.naic.org/cis_consumer_information.htm
- After, Prepaid Cremation Plans: https://www.after.com/prearrange




